Table of Contents
- What is the EU's 2040 target and why is it in the news this week?
- What exactly does the 90% emissions cut commit the EU to, and since when is it law?
- How does it fit between the 55% cut for 2030 and net zero by 2050?
- Why can up to 5 percentage points be met with international carbon credits?
- What happened at COP31 in Antalya that affects the target?
- Why is the leaked Irish Presidency compromise on the Emissions Trading System so contested?
- What do WWF and the Öko-Institut say is at risk if the ETS is softened?
- Where do carbon removals such as BioCCS and direct air capture come in?
- What are the next decision points to watch after COP31?
- The EU's Binding 90% Emissions Cut, Your Questions Answered: frequently asked questions
- What this reporting does not settle
- Where the target stands now
Key Takeaway
>
The EU’s Binding 90% Emissions Cut, Your Questions Answered starts from one settled fact: the amended European Climate Law entered into force in April 2026, making a 90% reduction in net greenhouse gas emissions by 2040, measured against 1990 levels, legally binding on the European Union. Up to 5 percentage points of that cut can be delivered through international carbon credits. The destination is now law. The Emissions Trading System reform meant to deliver it is still a proposal under negotiation, and that is where the November 2026 dispute sits.
Brussels and Antalya, November 2026. COP31 closed in Antalya, Türkiye on November 20, 2026, with the European Union’s 2040 climate target serving as one of the summit’s main reference points. The target itself is no longer in question: the amended European Climate Law has been in force since April 2026, which means the 90% figure is a legal obligation rather than a political aspiration.
What is in question is the machinery. The European Commission’s July 2026 reform of the Emissions Trading System, and the Council-level bargaining that has followed it, drew sharp criticism from WWF Germany, the Öko-Institut, Agora Energiewende and the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research during October and November 2026. The EU’s Binding 90% Emissions Cut, Your Questions Answered sets out what the law requires, what is still being traded, and what happens next.
About this reporting
>
Written by the INQ Daily world affairs desk, energy and climate policy beat. This piece is assembled from EU institutional publications, statements made by named EU officials, and analyses published by environmental organisations and research institutes between July 2025 and November 2026. No independent modelling was carried out for this article.
Transparency note
>
Emissions figures, Emissions Trading System revenue figures and the legislative timeline come from European Commission and Council publications. The criticism of the Emissions Trading System reform comes from NGO and think-tank analyses, including an assessment commissioned by WWF Germany from the Öko-Institut. Investment figures come from Allianz Research, a private-sector analysis rather than an official EU estimate. The 90% target is law; the Emissions Trading System parameters quoted here are proposals under negotiation as of November 21, 2026.
What is the EU’s 2040 target and why is it in the news this week?
The target is a legally binding 90% reduction in net European Union greenhouse gas emissions by 2040 against 1990 levels, written into the amended European Climate Law — and that is the starting point for The EU’s Binding 90% Emissions Cut, Your Questions Answered.
Antalya supplied the first news driver. COP31 ran from November 9 to 20, 2026, and on November 12 Commission President Ursula von der Leyen reaffirmed the 90% target there, linking climate action directly to energy security and citing disruption in global energy markets. On November 18, Climate Commissioner Wopke Hoekstra presented the EU’s Electrification Action Plan, which aims to double current electrification rates by 2040 as the route away from fossil fuels.
Figures published eight days before the summit supplied the second. The Commission’s 2026 Climate Action Progress Report, released on November 8, recorded EU net greenhouse gas emissions down 1.6% in 2025 against 2024, leaving total emissions 39% below 1990 levels while the EU economy has grown 74% since that baseline. The Commission uses that decoupling to defend the target’s feasibility. Critics use the same arithmetic to make the opposite point: 39% achieved against 90% required leaves the harder half of the work concentrated in the 2030s.
What exactly does the 90% emissions cut commit the EU to, and since when is it law?
The amended European Climate Law requires a 90% cut in net EU greenhouse gas emissions by 2040 against 1990 levels, and it entered into force in April 2026.
The obligation is bloc-wide and net. It binds the European Union as a whole rather than setting a free-standing quota for each capital, which means sectoral legislation — above all the Emissions Trading System and the effort-sharing rules — is what converts the headline figure into enforceable obligations on governments and operators. The law fixes the destination; the implementing files allocate the burden.
Getting there took twenty months, and the decisive unblocking came at the European Council summit in October 2025, which broke a political deadlock over the figure.
How the 2040 target became binding law
- July 2, 2025 — the European Commission proposes amending the European Climate Law to set a 90% cut by 2040.
- October 2025 — a European Council summit breaks the political deadlock on the target.
- November 5, 2025 — the Council keeps 90% but adds flexibilities: up to 5% international carbon credits, and ETS2 delayed to 2028.
- December 9, 2025 — a provisional political agreement is reached in trilogue between Parliament, Council and Commission.
- February 10, 2026 — the European Parliament plenary approves the interinstitutional agreement.
- March 6, 2026 — final approval follows a vote by member states in the Council.
- April 2026 — the amended European Climate Law enters into force and the 90% target becomes legally binding.
One word in the text carries disproportionate weight: net. Certified removals count against gross emissions, therefore the volume of removals assumed changes how much physical abatement the 90% figure actually demands.
How does it fit between the 55% cut for 2030 and net zero by 2050?
The 90% cut for 2040 is the midpoint milestone between the binding 55% reduction for 2030 and climate neutrality by 2050, all measured against 1990 levels and all set out in the same instrument, the European Climate Law.
| Milestone year | Required reduction vs 1990 | Legal status | Date it became binding |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2030 | 55% net reduction | Binding in the European Climate Law | Not stated |
| 2040 | 90% net reduction | Binding in the amended European Climate Law | April 2026 |
| 2050 | Climate neutrality (net zero) | Binding in the European Climate Law | Not stated |
| 2025 (for comparison) | 39% below 1990 | Reported outcome, not a target | Reported November 8, 2026 |
The pace problem follows from the Commission’s own numbers. Emissions stood 39% below 1990 at the end of 2025 and fell 1.6% in that single year, which means the annual rate of reduction has to rise sharply after 2030 for the 2040 step to hold. Consequently the implementation files, not the headline target, determine whether the ladder is climbable.
The 2040 step also carries the heaviest capital load. Allianz Research, in a 2025 analysis, put annual investment needs above €100 billion on a front-loaded path, with €2.3 trillion of grid investment required by 2050 and €220 billion for distribution networks by 2030 — distribution alone absorbing 56% of the total, with Germany, France and Italy accounting for half of that spending. Those are modelled private-sector figures, not EU budget commitments.
Why can up to 5 percentage points be met with international carbon credits?
The Council inserted that flexibility on November 5, 2025 as the price of keeping the headline figure at 90%, allowing up to 5 percentage points of the 2040 cut to be delivered through carbon credits purchased outside the European Union.
The mechanics are straightforward. Credits bought abroad count toward the EU total, which lowers the cost of the marginal tonne because abatement outside the bloc is cheaper than cutting emissions in European heavy industry. The German coalition government argued for including international offsets in the EU’s strategy, a position set out in its coalition treaty.
The objection is about credibility and displacement. Ottmar Edenhofer, director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, argued that the EU interim target must be met entirely domestically. Agora Energiewende warned that reliance on foreign credits risks undermining the credibility of EU decarbonisation. The causal chain they describe runs through investment: euros spent on credits abroad are euros not spent on European grids, electrification and industrial retooling, resulting in a thinner domestic asset base at precisely the point the 2050 target depends on it.
What happened at COP31 in Antalya that affects the target?
COP31 ran in Antalya, Türkiye from November 9 to 20, 2026, and the EU used it to reaffirm the 90% target and present electrification as the delivery route — nothing at the summit altered the legal text.
Its relevance is therefore external rather than legislative. Von der Leyen’s November 12 address restated the 90% commitment and tied climate action to energy security, citing disruption in global energy markets. Hoekstra followed on November 18 with the Electrification Action Plan, targeting a doubling of current electrification rates by 2040.
Members of the European Parliament used the summit to urge all parties to implement the climate commitments already on their books. That demand cuts both ways, because it sharpens the contrast between the message the EU delivered in Antalya and the softening its own Emissions Trading System file proposes at home.
Why is the leaked Irish Presidency compromise on the Emissions Trading System so contested?
The dispute turns on the Linear Reduction Factor — the annual rate at which allowances are withdrawn from the market — which the Commission proposed in July 2026 to cut from 4.4% to 3.7% a year for 2031 to 2035.
A lower Linear Reduction Factor leaves more allowances in circulation. More allowances weaken the carbon price signal, which means less financial pressure on heavy industry to abate. To compensate, the Commission proposed selling an additional 260 million allowances and using the proceeds to buy cheaper emission reductions outside the EU, capped at 5% of the total reduction.
| Parameter | Current or previous setting | Proposed setting | Status (Nov 21, 2026) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Linear Reduction Factor, 2031–2035 | 4.4% per year | 3.7% per year | Commission proposal, under negotiation |
| Additional allowances released | Not stated | 260 million | Commission proposal, under negotiation |
| International credits, share of total reduction | Not previously permitted | Up to 5% | Flexibility agreed; detailed rules pending |
| ETS2 start date | Not stated | 2028 | Agreed by the Council, November 5, 2025 |
These parameters are now being traded in Council negotiation, and the texts circulated at that stage are not published documents. The file is contested rather than merely technical because the Climate Law sets the destination while the Emissions Trading System sets the price. Any softening of the Linear Reduction Factor shifts abatement away from installations covered by the carbon market and onto sectors governed by weaker instruments.
What do WWF and the Öko-Institut say is at risk if the ETS is softened?
An analysis published on November 2, 2026 by the Öko-Institut for WWF Germany concluded that the Commission’s Emissions Trading System reform is incompatible with the 2040 target.
Its central finding is a supply number: the proposal increases the supply of allowances by up to 10% above projected demand. Excess supply depresses the carbon price, and a depressed price removes the economic reason to invest in abatement now rather than later.
Lisa Okken, industrial policy expert at WWF Germany, said the Commission was filling gaps with complicated accounting tricks and excessive flexibility, and warned that the burden shifts from heavy industry to agriculture and transport — sectors with fewer instruments available to deliver cuts, resulting in a larger residual gap as 2040 approaches.
The Commission’s case rests on competitiveness and energy security, and on the argument that the carbon market continues to fund the transition: Emissions Trading System revenues reached €43.2 billion in 2025, an 11% increase on 2024, according to the November 8, 2026 progress report. Both positions are on the record; neither has been adjudicated.
Where do carbon removals such as BioCCS and direct air capture come in?
Because the 2040 target is a net target, carbon removals — including bioenergy with carbon capture and storage and direct air capture — count against remaining gross emissions, which is why their accounting rules affect the real level of ambition.
The arithmetic is unforgiving in both directions. Every tonne of certified removal reduces the gross cut required, therefore the volume of removals assumed is as consequential as the headline percentage itself.
Three questions are unresolved as of November 2026: how removals are certified, whether industrial removals are admitted into the Emissions Trading System, and at what volume. No agreed figures exist, and stating any would be invention rather than reporting.
Critics treat removals and international credits as a single category of risk for the same structural reason. Both substitute for domestic abatement, which means the credibility argument advanced by Edenhofer and Agora Energiewende applies to removal accounting as directly as it does to offsets.
What are the next decision points to watch after COP31?
With the 90% target fixed in law, the decisions that determine whether it is met sit in the Emissions Trading System revision, the removals accounting rules and the ETS2 launch — not in any further negotiation of the target, which is not scheduled for reopening.
What to watch next
- Council and Parliament negotiation on the July 2026 Emissions Trading System revision, including the Linear Reduction Factor for 2031–2035
- The fate of the Council compromise texts under negotiation and any successor Presidency redraft
- Rules governing the 5% international credit flexibility: which credits qualify, and who verifies them
- Certification and accounting rules for carbon removals, including whether BioCCS and direct air capture enter the Emissions Trading System
- The ETS2 rollout, delayed to 2028, covering fuels used in buildings and road transport
- Delivery of the Electrification Action Plan presented by Wopke Hoekstra on November 18, 2026
- The next annual EU Climate Action Progress Report, which updates the gap between the 39% achieved and the 90% required
The sequencing matters. Emissions Trading System parameters are decided first, which means the residual burden left to agriculture, transport and buildings becomes knowable only after those numbers are settled.
The EU’s Binding 90% Emissions Cut, Your Questions Answered: frequently asked questions
Is the 90% target binding on individual member states?
No — the European Climate Law sets a bloc-wide net target for the European Union as a whole. National obligations arise through sectoral legislation such as the effort-sharing rules and the Emissions Trading System, which means each member state’s share is decided in those files rather than in the target itself. Changing the headline figure and changing a country’s obligation are two separate legislative acts.
What is the Linear Reduction Factor, in plain terms?
It is the annual rate at which the EU withdraws emission allowances from the Emissions Trading System. A higher factor shrinks supply faster and therefore pushes the carbon price up; a lower factor leaves more allowances available and holds the price down. That is why the proposed move from 4.4% to 3.7% for 2031 to 2035 is the single most disputed number in the file.
What does ETS2 cover and when does it start?
ETS2 is the separate emissions trading system for fuels used in buildings and road transport, and the Council pushed its start to 2028 on November 5, 2025. The delay reduces near-term cost exposure for households, which consequently pushes a larger share of the required abatement into the 2030s, when the annual reduction rate already has to accelerate.
How much revenue does the EU Emissions Trading System raise?
Revenues reached €43.2 billion in 2025, an 11% increase on the previous year, according to the Commission’s November 8, 2026 progress report. That money funds transition spending, which is why the Commission treats allowance sales as a financing instrument as well as a price signal — and why releasing 260 million extra allowances is defended on revenue grounds.
Can the 90% target be weakened later?
Changing the figure would require amending the European Climate Law again, which means a fresh Commission proposal plus Parliament and Council approval. That is a high procedural bar. The practical route to a weaker outcome runs through the implementation files instead, which is precisely the argument WWF Germany and the Öko-Institut made on November 2, 2026 about the Emissions Trading System reform.
How much investment does the 2040 target require?
Allianz Research put front-loaded annual investment needs above €100 billion, with €2.3 trillion of grid investment required by 2050 and €220 billion for distribution networks by 2030. Distribution networks absorb 56% of the total. These are modelled private-sector estimates rather than official EU budgeting, and they shift with assumptions about electricity demand.
What this reporting does not settle
The EU’s Binding 90% Emissions Cut, Your Questions Answered rests on documents and statements available up to November 21, 2026, and several things remain open.
- The 90% target is law, but the Emissions Trading System figures quoted here are proposals under negotiation and can change before adoption.
- Commission emissions figures are reported on a net basis and revised in later inventories, which means the 39% figure for 2025 is provisional.
- Council negotiating and Presidency compromise texts are not published documents, therefore their exact contents are not independently verifiable here.
- Investment estimates are modelled by Allianz Research rather than drawn from official EU budgeting, and modelled figures move with assumptions about electricity demand and grid build rates.
- The Öko-Institut analysis is a commissioned assessment for WWF Germany; the Commission does not accept its conclusion that the reform is incompatible with the target.
- Removal volumes and certification rules are unresolved, which means the domestic abatement genuinely required by 2040 cannot yet be stated precisely.
- This article covers the EU-level framework only; national implementation differs by member state.
Where the target stands now
The EU’s Binding 90% Emissions Cut, Your Questions Answered comes down to one distinction: the destination is fixed in law, the route is not. The amended European Climate Law has been binding since April 2026, and the EU entered 2026 with emissions 39% below 1990 levels after a 1.6% fall in 2025. Whether the remaining distance is covered depends on three files — the Emissions Trading System revision, the rules governing the 5% international credit flexibility, and removals accounting — rather than on any further argument about the headline number.
The next trigger is the Council and Parliament negotiation on the Emissions Trading System revision, where the Linear Reduction Factor for 2031 to 2035 is decided. INQ Daily will continue covering that file as it moves through both institutions.











